Research

Waves in space

Every lightning stroke, and every navy VLF transmitter, launches radio waves that leak through the ionosphere into space. There they become whistler-mode waves that can knock radiation belt electrons into the atmosphere.

From the ground to the radiation belts

Diagram of ducted and non-ducted whistler propagation paths through the plasmasphere
Whistler paths through the plasmasphere. Ducted waves stay field-aligned and can return to the ground; non-ducted waves turn oblique and reflect inside the magnetosphere. From Green et al. (2005).

Lightning strikes about 50 times a second around the world, and most of the energy in each stroke's electromagnetic pulse is at very low frequencies (VLF, 3–30 kHz). Most of that energy stays trapped between the ground and the ionosphere, but a fraction leaks upward. It is absorbed in the D-region, dispersed in the F-region, and then guided through the plasmasphere as whistler-mode waves, named for the falling tone they make when played as audio. Powerful navy VLF transmitters inject waves into space the same way.

Once in the magnetosphere, whistlers resonate with radiation belt electrons and scatter them in pitch angle. Some of those electrons fall into the atmosphere. Together with plasmaspheric hiss, chorus, and other natural waves, lightning-generated whistlers help set how long electrons survive in the belts and how much energy reaches the upper atmosphere. Our work follows that chain: how much wave energy gets into space, how it propagates once it is there, and what it does to the particles.

How much lightning energy reaches space?

Five stacked panels analyzing a Van Allen Probes burst containing whistlers
Finding whistlers in Van Allen Probes burst data. Top to bottom: magnetic spectrogram, the spectrogram filtered by the search coil noise level, ellipticity, wave normal angle, and clustering of individual whistlers.

Alexandra Wold's dissertation (2025) followed lightning-generated whistlers from source to space. She searched Van Allen Probes EFW burst-mode data for whistlers, used the wave normal angle to separate ducted from non-ducted waves, and mapped where they occur by L-shell and local time (Wold et al., 2024). She then matched whistlers to their source strokes in the GLD360 lightning database to test models of how much energy each stroke injects, and recomputed how strongly the ionosphere attenuates VLF waves on their way up, with different ionosphere models.

Six panels of modeled trans-ionospheric VLF attenuation versus latitude for day and night
Trans-ionospheric attenuation of VLF waves versus latitude at several frequencies, day and night, for different ionosphere models. Wold et al. (in preparation).

Those attenuation estimates feed directly into CANVAS. To turn the spectra CANVAS measures in orbit into a measure of how much the ionosphere absorbs, we run a full-wave propagation model (Lehtinen and Inan, 2009) at every frequency from 0.3 to 40 kHz and adjust the model ionosphere until it matches. Our ground-based receiver array, AVID, supplies the source spectrum on the ground.

Tracing waves through the magnetosphere

Where a whistler goes depends on its frequency, its initial direction, and the plasma it travels through. We use ray tracing to follow waves from their source through the plasmasphere, and full-wave models where ray tracing breaks down near the ionosphere.

  • When the VPM CubeSat failed to detect the space-based VLF transmitter on AFRL's DSX satellite during 27 conjunctions, ray tracing explained why: below about 4 kHz nearly all rays reflect before reaching low Earth orbit, and the most likely culprits at higher frequencies are the transmitting antenna's efficiency and the plasmasphere model (Reid et al., 2022).
  • Ground transmitter signals measured at low Earth orbit make a useful test of plasmasphere density models (Usanova et al., 2022).
  • With CEA and the British Antarctic Survey, we ray-traced VLF waves launched from low Earth orbit by active experiments and by lightning (Cerfolli et al., 2025).
Observed and modeled whistler spectrograms side by side
Observed (left) and modeled (right) spectrograms of a lightning-generated whistler. From Alexandra Wold's Ph.D. dissertation (Wold, 2025).

Waves meet particles

To predict how whistlers scatter electrons, radiation belt models use diffusion coefficients built from average wave properties: amplitude, frequency spectrum, and wave normal angle. Alex Shane tested those averages against the waves themselves. Event by event, lightning-generated whistler distributions vary far more than averaged models assume (Shane et al., 2025), and the bounce-averaged diffusion coefficients are sensitive to how whistler properties change with latitude (Shane et al., 2026). Using low-altitude data, he also measured electron lifetimes at low Earth orbit and compared them with estimates from the Van Allen Probes (Shane et al., 2023).

The effects reach higher energies than once thought. Working with Lauren Blum, then-undergraduate Max Feinland found lightning driving bursts of relativistic electron precipitation from the inner radiation belt (Feinland et al., 2024).

Other waves matter too. Paraksh Vankawala's dissertation (2026) used computer vision to detect and classify plasma waves in Van Allen Probes data, to explore where plasmaspheric hiss comes from. With collaborators we have studied EMIC-driven precipitation seen by ELFIN (Capannolo et al., 2024) and chorus-driven variability in the ionosphere (Chen et al., 2026). The atmospheric side of this story, where precipitating electrons deposit their energy, is on our Radiation in space page.

Measuring waves from orbit

We build our own wave receivers. VPM's micro-broadband receiver measured one magnetic and one electric component from 1 to 30 kHz (Marshall et al., 2021). CANVAS, launched in April 2026, goes much further. Its receiver records three magnetic components, from search coils built by LPC2E in Orléans, and two electric components from 0.3 to 40 kHz. It computes full power and cross spectra every second, all the time. That is enough to find each wave's direction, polarization, and Poynting flux, and so to build a climatology of the VLF energy entering space from lightning and transmitters. More about the receiver is on our Space instrumentation page.

Modeled VLF wave energy at 700 km altitude above a ground transmitter
Modeled wave energy at 700 km altitude at 4.32 kHz, comparing the full-wave method with a simpler illumination model. This kind of model is what we will compare with CANVAS spectra.
Selected papers
  1. Shane, A. D., R. A. Marshall, and Q. Ma (2026), Sensitivity of bounce-averaged diffusion coefficients to the latitudinal variability of lightning generated whistlers, JGR Space Physics. doi
  2. Chen, L., G. D. Berland, R. A. Marshall, and J. Liang (2026), Chorus wave-induced ionospheric variability, Geophysical Research Letters, 53, e2026GL123346. doi
  3. Shane, A. D., R. A. Marshall, A. M. Wold, X. C. Shen, and W. Li (2025), Lightning generated whistlers: Variability of event-based wave distributions, JGR Space Physics, 130, e2025JA034164. doi
  4. Cerfolli, L., J.-F. Ripoll, R. B. Horne, A. M. Wold, and R. A. Marshall (2025), Ray tracing of very low frequency waves produced by active experiments or lightning events at low Earth orbit, Comptes Rendus. Physique, 26. doi
  5. Wold, A. M., R. A. Marshall, D. M. Malaspina, and A. D. Shane (2024), Prevalence and propagation of lightning-generated whistlers in Van Allen Probes EFW burst data, JGR Space Physics, 129, e2024JA032781. doi
  6. Feinland, M., L. W. Blum, R. A. Marshall, L. Gan, M. Shumko, and M. Looper (2024), Lightning-induced relativistic electron precipitation from the inner radiation belt, Nature Communications, 15, 8721. doi
  7. Capannolo, L., R. Marshall, W. Li, G. Berland, et al. (2024), Unraveling the atmospheric energy input and ionization due to EMIC-driven electron precipitation from ELFIN observations, AGU Advances, 5, e2023AV001096. doi
  8. Shane, A. D., R. A. Marshall, S. G. Claudepierre, and J. M. Pettit (2023), Electron lifetimes measured at LEO: Comparison with RBSP estimates and pitch angle resolved lifetimes, JGR Space Physics. doi
  9. Reid, R. A., R. A. Marshall, M. J. Starks, M. E. Usanova, G. R. Wilson, W. R. Johnston, et al. (2022), Active VLF transmission experiments between the DSX and VPM spacecraft, JGR Space Physics, 127. doi
  10. Usanova, M. E., R. A. Reid, W. Xu, R. A. Marshall, M. J. Starks, and G. R. Wilson (2022), Using VLF transmitter signals at LEO for plasmasphere model validation, JGR Space Physics. doi
  11. Marshall, R. A., A. Sousa, R. Reid, G. Wilson, M. Starks, D. Ramos, et al. (2021), The micro-Broadband Receiver (μBBR) on the Very-Low-Frequency Propagation Mapper CubeSat, Earth and Space Science, 8, e2021EA001951. doi
  12. Lehtinen, N. G., and U. S. Inan (2009), Full-wave modeling of transionospheric propagation of VLF waves, Geophysical Research Letters, 36(3). doi
  13. Green, J. L., S. Boardsen, L. Garcia, W. W. L. Taylor, S. F. Fung, and B. W. Reinisch (2005), On the origin of whistler mode radiation in the plasmasphere, JGR, 110, A03201. doi

Dissertations: Wold, A. M. (2025), Lightning-generated whistlers from source to space; Vankawala, P. M. (2026), Exploring the origins of plasmaspheric hiss through a computer vision guided wave analysis; Reid, R. (2024). See Books & theses.